Near Decatur Square, 2 old motels, more floated for redevelopment

Josh Green

Thu, 02/20/2025 – 15:11

A unique palette for potential redevelopment has recently hit the market near downtown Decatur’s bustling food, drink, and retail blocks.

The assemblage of three contiguous properties on Church Street—two 1960s motels and a brick single-family home structure—is being marketed as a “once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to develop a landmark project” within a quick walk of Historic Decatur Square, according to the Keller Williams Realty Intown ATL listing.

The three properties totaling .62 acres were listed last week for $10.5 million.

Situated about three blocks north of popular Decatur establishments such as Leon’s Full Service restaurant, the addresses span from 909 to 921 Church St.

Today they’re home to the standalone house, Super 8 by Wyndham Decatur, and at the north edge, the Decatur Inn.

The Super 8 motel and, at right, the single-family home structure included in the $10.5-million sale. Google Maps

Decatur Inn, the northernmost property for sale, today. Google Maps

Immediately to the east are the pretty, historic grounds of Decatur Cemetery. The site being relatively flat and rectangular is called a selling point.

The strong Walk Score (86/100) and Transit Score (85) can’t hurt, but the Bike Score (55) could seem weirdly low, especially with Decatur’s new Church Street cycle track at the doorstep.

According to listings, the site’s current zoning would support a variety of redevelopments; larger-scale projects would require a zoning change.

Possibilities could include condos over commercial spaces, or a luxury condo project with walkability and scenic views over the graveyard and DeKalb County’s county seat, per sellers.

Looking east across the three properties in question, with the historic graveyard next door. Google Maps

The Church Street properties in relation to the bulk of downtown Decatur, located a few blocks to the south.Google Maps

Another option could be a high-end retirement community within a short walk of leisure and healthcare perks around downtown, per Keller Williams.

“Whether you’re considering a luxury townhome community, mixed-use residential/retail project, or a specialized development like a retirement home,” reads the spiel, “this prime site offers the foundation for extraordinary returns and community impact.”

Note: The assemblage is being offered only as a package deal and won’t be sold piecemeal, per sellers.

Which begs the age-old question: What should go here?

Overview of the three contiguous properties in question, with Historic Decatur Cemetery at right. Keller Williams Realty Intown ATL